9urn:lsid:arphahub.com:pub:F9D0807C-3C52-5A33-8AB6-FB2607A29353urn:lsid:zoobank.org:pub:E14246FD-79C0-4B14-A52F-3F6A3D7ECCA8Subterranean BiologySB1768-14481314-2615Pensoft Publishers10.3897/subtbiol.14.77001320Review articlesStygobitic oligochaetes (Annelida, Clitellata) in Poland with remarks on their distribution in Central EuropeDumnickaElzbieta1dumnicka@iop.krakow.plInstitute of Nature Conservation, Polish Academy of Sciences, al. Mickiewicza 33, 31-120 Kraków, PolandInstitute of Nature Conservation, Polish Academy of SciencesKrakowPoland
20141820141415248C47CA62-A55C-FF8D-BA44-FFD6FF9174455752331142014972014Elzbieta DumnickaThis is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
In Poland eleven stygobitic species have been found, whereas in Central Europe their number reached 23 species. Lumbriculidae are represented by 10 species, Enchytraeidae by seven, Naididae by three, whereas Dorydrilidae and Lumbricidae by two and singular species, respectively. Some species are known from Central Europe exclusively, but majority of them have wider distribution.
Subterranean watersinvertebrate faunaCitation
Dumnicka E (2014) Stygobitic oligochaetes (Annelida, Clitellata) in Poland with remarks on their distribution in Central Europe. Subterranean Biology 14: 15–24. doi: 10.3897/subtbiol.14.7700
Introduction
Taking into account their morphological features stygobitic and stygoxenic oligochaete species are indistinguishable. Therefore for this taxonomical group the attribution to stygobionts is based on species distribution. Species found exclusively in subterranean waters (including shallow groundwater sensu Schmidt and Hahn (2012)) are treated as stygobionts. Sometimes they could be found in benthic samples also, mainly in springs and occasionally in running waters during low water level periods when rivers are fed directly by underground waters (Allan 1995). In such a situation other stygobionts, for example Niphargus tatrensis can be also found (Dumnicka 2005). Among oligochaetes there are many stygophilic species that live and reproduce successfully in surface and subterranean waters whereas stygoxenic species could survive for some time in underground waters but do not reproduce effectively in this environment.
The studies on oligochaetous annelids in subterranean waters of Poland as well as other countries of Central Europe: Czechoslovakia (now Czech Republik and Slovakia), Germany and Hungary started many years ago (Vejdovsky 1882, Lengersdorf 1929, Mohr 1929, Dudich 1932, Stammer 1936, Hrabě 1937, 1942), but generally they were done sporadically and in restricted areas. Nevertheless successive studies allowed to add subsequent species to the list of stygobitic oligochaetes or to find new localities of their occurrence. The state of knowledge about stygobitic oligochaetes was first summarized by Juget and Dumnicka (1986) and recently by Des Châtelliers et al. (2009). Moreover information that accumulated in the last years and some data not considered by Des Châtelliers et al. (2009) was taken into account in the present study: for Austria – paper by Danielopol and Pospisil (2001), for Czech Republik - by Hrabě (1981) and Schenkova et al. (2010), for Germany – by Stein et al. (2012), for Slovakia – by Šporka (1992) and Bitušik et al. (2010), for Poland – by Dumnicka (1998, 2000, 2005, 2009a, 2009b) and Dumnicka and Koszałka (2005).
The current list of stygobitic oligochaete species from Poland and Central Europe is presented and the origin of species known exclusively from Central European countries is discussed. The probable ways of recolonisation after the last glaciation period by some species known from southern Europe is also discussed.
ResultsSpecies distribution in Poland
At present eleven stygobitic species are known from Polish territory (Table 1), the majority of them was found in one geographical region. Some of them were collected from a very restricted area e.g. in one or two closely situated localities and in a very small number of specimens, for example Trichodrilus spelaeus – one individual in a pool situated on the bottom of an adit in Klecienko (Sudetes) (Moszyński 1936); Trichodrilus pragensis – a few individuals in two caves in Sudetes (Dumnicka 2000), Haber zavreli - two individuals in two wells in Beskidy Mts (Kasprzak 1973) and Fridericia dissimilis - seven mature individuals in an intermittent spring in Sudetes (Dumnicka 1998).
The others, known from a limited area in Poland formed significant part of oligochaete taxocens, e.g. Gianius aquaedulcis in three closely situated springs located in Warta drainage area (Dumnicka 2009a) and Enchytraeus polonicus in a few caves of Kraków Częstochowa Upland (Dumnicka 1981). Among species known from singular localization only Rhyacodrilus subterraneus was stated in northern Poland (Mazurian Lakeland), in interstitial waters of a small stream (Dumnicka and Koszałka 2005). In contrast, some other species, such as Enchytraeus dominicae, Cernosvitoviella parviseta, Trichodrilus moravicus and Trichodrilus cernosvitovi are widely distributed in underground water bodies of various categories (Dumnicka 2000). Up to now all enchytraeids (4 species) and Trichodrilus spelaeus were found only in Poland.
Distribution of stygobitic oligochaetes in Poland.
The number of stygobitic oligochaete species known from separate countries of Central Europe varying from two in Austria to eleven in Poland (Fig. 1). This number likely reflects research effort rather than the true diversity of stygobitic species in each country.
The list of stygobitic oligochaetes found at present in Central Europe is not long – it contains 23 species (Table 2) among them five (mainly enchytraeids) are known from Poland exclusively. Family Lumbriculidae is represented in these countries by 10 species and Enchytraeidae by seven, moreover Naididae, Dorydrilidae and Lumbricidae are represented by a few or singular species.
Among stygobitic oligochaete fauna studied in all Central European countries some endemic species (e.g. known exclusively from one geographic region in one country) have been encountered. They are represented by: the above-mentioned Trichodrilus spelaeus (from Poland), Helodrilus mozsaryorum (Baradla cave, Hungary) (Zicsi et al. 1999) and Stylodrilus absoloni (Moravian Karst, Czech Republik) (Hrabě 1981). It seems that Dorydrilus tetrathecus, and Trichodrilus medius, both known from a few closely situated localities in Germany (Hrabě 1960) could be also treated as endemics. Moreover, up to now, two Trichodrilus species (Trichodrilus moravicus and Trichodrilus tatrensis) (Table 2) are known from a few countries of Central Europe solely. Trichodrilus moravicus is known from various subterranean habitats in three neighboring countries (Table 2), whereas Trichodrilus tatrensis was found mainly in bottom samples of some streams flowing below the caves in Slovakian part of Tatra Mts. (Hrabě 1981) and in subterranean waters in Germany (Hrabě 1960). The remaining Lumbriculidae and all Naididae species known from Central Europe have wider distribution: Lumbriculidae and Gianius aquaedulcis are known mainly from southern Europe whereas Haber zavreli and Dorydrilus michaelseni from Great Britain also (Table 2). The distribution of Rhyacodrilus subterraneus is dissimilar – this species is known from subterranean waters of Central Europe and Belgium (Martin et al. 2009), and from cold surface waters of the northern part of this continent (Erséus et al. 2005). It was also found in mountain streams of France and Spain (see Dumnicka and Koszałka 2005).
The studies on Enchytraeidae from the discussed environment were only done in three central European countries: Hungary, Poland and recently in Germany (Stein et al. 2012). Stygobitic species found in these countries belong to aquatic (Cernosvitoviella) or semi-aquatic, as well as terrestrial genera (Enchytraeus, Enchytronia, Fridericia) and they have limited distribution (Table 2).
Number of stygobitic oligochaete species known from the countries of Central Europe.
https://binary.pensoft.net/fig/9364
Distribution of stygobitic oligochaetes known from Central Europe. References concerning species distribution in Poland are in Table 1.
The state of knowledge on stygobitic oligochaete fauna in each of the studied countries of Central Europe varies. Aquatic oligochaete fauna was not studied in Hungary whereas there is plenty of information concerning distribution of such fauna in subterranean waters of Germany, Czech Republic, Slovakia and southern part of Poland. Representatives of Enchytraeidae family were studied only in Poland, Hungary and recently in Germany.
Although the diversity of aquatic subterranean oligochaete fauna in Central Europe is distinctly smaller than in Mediterranean countries (Giani et al. 2001, Des Châtelliers et al. 2009, Giani et al. 2011, Achurra and Rodriguez 2008) there are some stygobitic species, known exclusively from this region. Perhaps some of them are true endemics or they have not been found yet in other geographic regions. The widening of the distribution area as a result of intensive studies can be seen in the case of Guestphalinus wiardi, known for many years exclusively from Germany and then found in Slovenia by Hrabě (1973). Stygobitic oligochaete species from family Dorydrilidae (Dorydrilus tetrathecus) and Lumbriculidae such as Trichodrilus moravicus, T. medius, T. tatrensis, T. spelaeus and Stylodrilus absoloni, known only from subterranean waters of Central Europe probably diversified in this region before the Tertiary or during the warm Pleistocene periods, when that area was not glaciated, and they survived in singular or several refugia.
Within the genus Trichodrilus some of the species have high similarity of various anatomical structures (including genital organs) demonstrating their close relationship to other species living both in epigean and hypogean waters of small, separated areas. Molecular studies should allow to establish the degree of their separation (autonomous or sister species, or same species with some morphological and anatomical differences).
The rarity of stygobitic oligochaete species occurrence makes all studies on their distribution, speciation and ecology very difficult. They are usually found in an extremely small number of samples taken from subterranean waters and even the confirmation of species occurrence and findings of new localities are very difficult. During the studies of 261 localities in Slovenia (Giani et al. 2011) among 19 stygobitic oligochaete species known earlier from this country, the occurrence of only three of them was confirmed. Moreover, ten other stygobionts were found on one to eight sampling stations and Trichodrilus pragensis - the most frequently found species - was observed at ten sampling stations (Giani et al. 2011). During large-scale studies on subterranean invertebrate fauna from various geographical regions in Germany, only Dorydrilus michaelseni was found (Stein et al. 2012) beside epigean oligochaete species.
The majority of stygobitic species found in Central Europe (except for Enchytraeidae) is known from southern Europe. They could have recolonized subterranean waters of Central Europe after glacial/interglacial periods along water courses - especially along the Danube River. Its catchment area covers large parts of Czech Republic, Slovakia, Germany and Austria. Such migration towards the north part of Germany along the Rhine River was also possible. Some species could have migrated by underground connections between catchments area of Danube – Oder and Danube –Vistula River in Poland. The presence of such connection is well documented for the Danube – Oder tributaries (Sudetes, Śnieżnik Massive). Kleśnica stream (Poland) is connected by a few kilometers long underground flow with Morava stream (Czech Republic) (Ciężkowski et al. 1996). In the Tatra Mts. such a connection was not confirmed by water-tracing tests, but the existence of such a flow is assumed (Gradziński et al. 2009). The recharge area was located on the southern part of the higher part of the mountains in Slovakia where there is a small sinkhole in the Cicha Valley (catchment of the Danube River). The discharge is probably through resurgences located at the foot of the northern slopes of the mountains in the Bystra Valley in Poland (catchment of the Vistula River). Migration along water courses facilitates wide spreading of species living in hyporheic waters, which usually have wider distribution than those living in phreatic waters. Such a model of species distribution was also mentioned for the genus Niphargus (Karaman and Ruffo 1986). Probably the migration of stygobionts of marine origin, mainly known from southern Europe (Sambugar et al. 1999) took place by latitudinal ice – marginal river valleys. The distribution of Gianius aquaedulcis in northern and central parts of Germany and Poland could be the example of such a migration.
It seems that the occurrence of some oligochaete species in epigean or hypogean habitats depends on water temperature. For example, Rhyacodrilus subterraneus was not found in epigean waters in Poland despite many studies done on their oligochaete fauna, but it lives in epigean streams of northern Europe and mountain streams of France and Spain (see Dumnicka and Koszałka 2005). Trichodrilus tatrensis is also known from subterranean (Hrabě 1960) or cold epigean waters (Šporka 1992, Bitušik et al. 2010). Such a species could be named “local” stygobionts in regions where they occur in subterranean waters only.
All the enchytraeid species described and found up to now in the subterranean environment of Central Europe are listed in Table 2, but due to the taxonomic revision began by Schmelz and Collado (2010) the determination of their exact number is not possible for the moment.
Conclusions
Stygobitic oligochaete fauna of Central Europe is not rich, comprising only 23 species. They were found in various subterranean habitats, but the most frequently in interstitial waters. Some species (14, half of them represents family Enchytraeidae) are known only from Central Europe what suggests their speciation in situ and survival during the glacial/interglacial periods in refugia. The species having a wide distribution could have recolonised subterranean waters of Central Europe along water courses from non-glaciated regions of southern Europe.
ReferencesAchurraARodriguezP (2008) Biodiversity of groundwater oligochaetes from a karst unit in northern Iberian Peninsula: ranking subterranean sites for conservation management.605: 159–171. doi: 10.1007/s10750-008-9331-2AllanJD (1995) Chapman & Hall, London, Glasgow, Weinheim, New York, Tokyo, Melbourne, Madras, 388 pp. doi: 10.1007/978-94-011-0729-7BitušikPŠporkaFKrnoI (2010) Benthic invertebrate fauna of two alpine lakes over the last century: The value of historical data for interpreting environmental changes.65: 884–891. doi: 10.2478/s11756-010-0102-yCiężkowskiWKryzaHKryzaJPulinaMŘehakJStaśkoSTarkaR (1996) Wody podziemne i wpływ czynników antropogenicznych na ich zasoby i jakość. In: JahnAKozłowskiSPulinaM (Eds) Masyw Śnieżnika zmiany w środowisku przyrodniczym., 147–167.DanielopolDLPospisilP (2001) Hidden biodiversity in the groundwater of the Danube Flood Plain National Park (Austria).10: 1711–1721. doi: 10.1023/A:1012098706986DesChâtelliers MJugetJLafontMMartinP (2009) Subterranean aquatic Oligochaeta.54: 678–690. doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2427.2009.02173.xDudichE (1932) Speläologische Monographien 13, Wien, 246 pp.DumnickaE (1981) Skąposzczety (Oligochaeta) jaskiń południowej Polski. Rocznik Muzeum Okręgowego w Częstochowie 5, Przyroda 2: 15–22.DumnickaE (1996) Aquatic Oligochaeta and Aphanoneura from the souterrains of Central Europe with description of a new Enchytraeus species.23: 167–171.DumnickaE (1998) A new species of Fridericia (Oligochaeta: Enchytraeidae) found in a spring in the Sudety mountains (Poland).34: 155–158. doi: 10.1051/limn/1998014DumnickaE (2000) Studies on Oligochaeta taxocens in streams, interstitial and cave waters of southern Poland.43: 339–392.DumnickaE (2005) Stygofauna associated with springfauna in southern Poland.3: 39–36.DumnickaE (2009a) New for Poland tubificid (Oligochaeta) species from karstic springs.57: 395–401.DumnickaE (2009b) Diversity of oligochaete fauna inhabiting epigean and hypogean sectors of a stream flowing through a non-karstic cave in Beskidy Mts. (Poland).7: 41–46.DumnickaEKoszałkaJ (2005) The effect of drought on Oligochaeta communities in small woodland streams.60: 143–150. doi: 10.1051/limn:20054130183ErséusCRotaETimmTGrimmRHealyBLundbergS (2005) Riverine and riparian clitellates of three drainages in southern Sweden.41: 183–194.GianiNSambugarBMartinez-AnsemilEMartinPSchmelzRM (2011) The groundwater oligochaetes (Annelida, Clitellata) of Slovenia.9: 85–102. doi: 10.3897/subtbiol.9.2512GradzińskiMHercmanHKicińskaDBarczykGBellaPHolubékP (2009) Kras tatrzański – rozwój wiedzy w ostatnich trzydziestu latach.57: 674–684.HraběS (1937) Contribution à l’étude du genre Trichodrilus et description de deux espèces nouvelles.13(32): 1–23.HraběS (1942) Poznamky o zviženě ze studni a pramenu na Slovensku. Sbornik Kl. Prir.24: 23–30.HraběS (1960) Oligochaeta limicola from the collection of dr. S. Husmann. Spisy Prir. Fak.415: 245–277.HraběS (1973) On a collection of Oligochaeta from various parts of Yugoslavia. Biol.21: 39–50.HraběS (1981) Vodni malostetinatci (Oligochaeta) Československa. Acta Univ. Carolinae 1979, Biologica 1–2: 1–167.JugetJDumnickaE (1986) Oligochaeta (incl. Aphanoneura) des eaux souterraines continentales. In: BotosaneanuL (Ed) Stygofauna Mundi., 234–249.KasprzakK (1973) Notatki o faunie skąposzczetów Polski, I.18: 405–434.KasprzakK (1979) Skąposzczety (Oligochaeta) Pienin. II. Naididae, Tubificidae, Haplotaxidae, Lumbriculidae, Branchiobdellidae.24: 57–80.LengersdorfF (1929) Beitrage zur Kenntnis der Höhlenfauna Westfalens.85: 106–108.MartinPDe BroyerCFiersFMichelGSablonRWoutersK (2009) Biodiversity of Belgian groundwater fauna in relation to environmental conditions.54: 814–829. doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2427.2008.01993.xMohrE (1929) Biologische Untersuchungen in der Segeberger Höhle. Schrift. Natur. Ver. Schlesw.19: 1–25.MoszyńskiA (1936) Die Höhlenfauna des Glazer Schneeberges. 9. Ein neuer Vertreter der Gattung Trichodrilus Clap. (Trichodrilus spelaeus nov. spec.) aus dem Stollen in Neu-Klessengrund. Beitr. Biol.2: 214–216.SambugarBGianiNMartinez-AnsemilE (1999) Groundwater oligochaetes from Southern-Europe. Tubificidae with marine phyletic affinities: new data with description of a new species, review and consideration on their origin.26: 107–116.SchenkovaJPařilPPetřivalskaKBojkovaJ (2010) Aquatic oligochaetes (Annelida: Clitellata) of the Czech Republik: check-list, new records and ecological remarks.2676: 29–44.SchmelzRMColladoR (2010) A guide to European terrestrial and freshwater species of Enchytraeidae (Oligochaeta).82: 1–176.SchmidtSIHahnHJ (2012) What is groundwater and what does this mean to fauna? – An opinion.42: 1–6. doi: 10.1016/j.limno.2011.08.002StammerHJ (1936) Die Höhlenfauna des Glatzer Schneeberges. 8. Die Wasserfauna der Schneeberghöhlen. Beitr. Biol.2: 199–214.SteinHGrieblerChBerkhoffSMatzkeDFuchsAHahnHJ (2012) Stygoregions – a promising approach to a bioregional classification of groundwater systems. Scientific Reports 2, 673: 1–9. doi: 10.1038/srep00673ŠporkaF (1992) Maloštetinavce (Oligochaeta) jazier v Zapadnych Tatrach.32: 139–148.VejdovskyF (1882) Thierische Organismen der Brunnenwässer von Prag. Prag. 70 pp.ZicsiADozsa-FarkasKCsuzdiCS (1999) Terrestrial oligochaetes of the Aggtelek National Park. In: MahunkaS (Ed.) The fauna of the Aggtelek National Park., 39–43.