Research Article |
Corresponding author: Randy Gibson ( randy_gibson@fws.gov ) Academic editor: Thomas Sawicki
© 2021 Randy Gibson, Benjamin T. Hutchins, Jean K. Krejca, Peter H. Diaz, Peter S. Sprouse.
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the CC0 Public Domain Dedication.
Citation:
Gibson R, Hutchins BT, Krejca JK, Diaz PH, Sprouse PS (2021) Stygobromus bakeri, a new species of groundwater amphipod (Amphipoda, Crangonyctidae) associated with the Trinity and Edwards aquifers of central Texas, USA. Subterranean Biology 38: 19-45. https://doi.org/10.3897/subtbiol.38.61787
|
A new stygobitic groundwater amphipod species, Stygobromus bakeri sp. nov., is described from 4 central Texas limestone karst springs; John Knox Spring (Comal County), Jacob’s Well (Hays County), Mormon Spring (Travis County) and Salado Springs (Bell County). This species belongs to the predominately western Nearctic hubbsi species group of Stygobromus and differs from other species in the group by gnathopod 1 with row of 4 to 5 setae posterior to the defining angle, pereopods 6 and 7 with broadly expanded bases and distinct distoposterior lobes, gnathopods 1 and 2 with 2 rows of 3 singly inserted setae on the inner palm, and uropod 3 with single, slightly distal peduncular seta. Habitat, sympatric groundwater species, and conservation issues are discussed.
cave, crenobiont, interstitial crustacean, karst, spring, stygobiont, stygobite, subterranean, sympatric, troglomorphy
The Nearctic amphipod genus Stygobromus Cope, 1872 (Amphipoda, Crangonyctidae) currently includes 137 described species and 4 subspecies in the United States and Canada (
Stygobromus species of the hubbsi group are recorded in a variety of groundwater habitats including caves, wells, the hyporheic zone of surface streams, karstic and non-karstic springs, and hypotelminorheic seeps. Two species live in the depths (5–495 m) of Lake Tahoe (California and Nevada) although
Many groundwater habitats and groundwater-obligate organisms are at risk from a myriad of threats, including groundwater contamination, physical habitat destruction (e.g. gravel mining), and groundwater extraction (
Specimens were collected from karst springs using 150–250 µm mesh drift nets and using multiple techniques at an underwater cave, Jacob’s Well (Fig.
Comal, Hays, and Travis counties, Texas spring sites for Stygobromus bakeri sp. nov. Jacob’s Well A cave entrance B second constriction point (30 m water depth), Stygobromus bakeri sp. nov. were found deeper than this point C drift net at first constriction point (23 m water depth). John Knox Ranch D Blue Hole, perennial headwaters of Carper’s Creek E John Knox Spring issuing within Blue Hole. Mormon Spring #3 F Spring exposed under boat dock during drought G drift net on spring site. Photograph credit: Jean Krejca (A–C); courtesy of John Knox Ranch (D); Randy Gibson (E); Peter Sprouse (F, G).
Specimens were dissected, and mouthparts and appendages were mounted in glycerin. Images and measurements were acquired at multiple magnifications and focal points using an Olympus BX-45 compound stereomicroscope and Nikon DS-5M digital camera. Images were imported into Abode Illustrator Creative Suite 5 software and line drawing illustrations were produced using a Wacom Cintiq 22HD Interactive Pen Display. Nomenclature for setal arrangement on the mandibular palps follows Cole (1980) for segment 2 and
Order Amphipoda Latreille, 1816
Suborder Senticaudata Lowery & Myers, 2013
Infraorder Gammarida Latreille, 1802
Parvorder Crangonyctidira Bousfield, 1973
Superfamily Crangonyctoidea Bousfield, 1973
Family Crangonyctidae Bousfield, 1963; emended by Holsinger 1977
Genus Stygobromus Cope, 1872
USA, Texas, Comal County, John Knox Ranch, John Knox Spring (29.9642, 98.1956).
All sites are in Texas, USA. Holotype female (4.6 mm) – Comal County, John Knox Ranch, John Knox Spring: collected by Randy Gibson (RG), 6 May 2010, dissected slide mounts Texas State University Aquifer Biodiversity Collection. Allotype male (3.1 mm) – Comal County, John Knox Ranch, John Knox Spring: collected by RG, 16 April 2010. Paratypes – John Knox Spring: juvenile (1.7 mm) collected by RG, 6 January 2010; 2 males (3.5 and 3.6 mm) and juvenile (2.4 mm) collected by RG, 6 April 2010; 2 males (2.5 and 3.4 mm) collected by RG, 2 May 2010; juvenile (2.4 mm) collected by RG, 6 May 2010; damaged female (4.5 mm) collected by RG, 10 May 2010; 2 males (3.1 mm and 4.1 mm) collected by RG, 13 May 2010; male (3.5 mm) and juvenile (2.3 mm) collected by RG, 21 May 2010. – Hays County, Jacob’s Well (30.0345, -98.1261): male (4.2 mm) collected by Jean Krejca (JK), 21 October 2009; female (4.5 mm) collected by JK, 6 May 2010; female (3.5 mm) collected (≈ 43 m depth) by JK and James Brown, 4 August 2010; brooding female (4.4 mm), male (4.1 mm) and 2 juveniles collected by JK 31 May 2011; 2 males (4.4 and 2.9 mm) collected by JK, 16 June 2013; male (3.2 mm) collected by Matt Turner, 8 September 2013.
– Travis County, Mormon Spring no. 3 (30.3132, -97.7747): 1 damaged female (4.4 mm) collected by P. Sprouse, 30 January 2017 (Zara # 9450, TMM # 91,955). – Bell County, Middle Robertson Spring (Robertson Springs Complex) (30.9444, -97.5410): female (4.2 mm) collected by Andy Gluesenkamp, 12 Dec 2009; juvenile (1.7 mm) collected by RG and Pete Diaz (PD), 30 July 2015; male (2.7 mm) collected by PD, 26 April 2017. Sam Bass Spring (Robertson Springs Complex) (30.9444, -97.5410): male (4.5 mm) collected (drift net) by PD and RG, 1 Mar 2016. Upper Ludwigia Spring (Robertson Springs Complex) (30.9444, -97.5411): male (3.1 mm), collected (drift net) by PD, 20 January – 6 June 2017. Creek Spring (Robertson Springs Complex) (30.9445, -97.5414): male (3.0 mm) collected by PD, 12 April 2018; 2 males (4.1 and 3.2 mm) collected by PD, 27 November 2018. Big Boiling Spring (Downtown Springs Complex) (30.9437, -97.5366): male (3.2 mm) collected by RG and PD, 25 September 2015. Anderson Spring (Downtown Springs Complex (30.9441, -97.5346): damaged specimen (2.9 mm) collected (drift net) by PD, 1 November 2016–20 January 2017. Whole paratypes are deposited in the National Museum of Natural History, Smithsonian Institution (
Small stygobitic species similar to most members of the hubbsi group with mature females larger than males, gnathopod 2 larger than gnathopod 1, posterior margin of gnathopod 1 typically shorter than palm, and telson as long as broad with shallow notch in apical margin. Distinguished from other hubbsi group species by gnathopods 1 and 2 with 2 rows of 3 singly inserted setae on the inner palm, and combination of following characters: gnathopod 1 with row of 4 to 5 setae posterior to the defining angle (compare to S. quatsinensis Holsinger & Shaw, 1986 with 2 or 3 postmarginal setae, 3 hubbsi group species have 1 or 2 postmarginal setae and all others are lacking); pereopods 6 and 7 with broadly expanded bases and distinct distoposterior lobes (similar to S. salturus Wang & Holsinger, 2001); and uropod 3 with single, slightly distal peduncular seta (similar to S. lanensis Wang & Holsinger, 2001).
Female (4.6 mm). Antenna 1 (Fig.
Stygobromus bakeri sp. nov., Holotype ♀ (4.6 mm), John Knox Spring, Comal Co., Texas A1 antenna 1 A2 antenna 2 Li lower lip Mp maxilliped Mx1 maxilla 1 Mx2 maxilla 2. Paratype ♂ (3.1 mm), John Knox Spring, Comal Co., TX. lMdb left mandible and mandibular palp rMdb right mandible. Scale bars: 0.05 mm (Li, Mp, Mx1, Mx2, lMdb, rMdb); 0.1 mm (A1, A2).
Gnathopod 1
(Fig.
Gnathopod 2
(Fig.
Pereopod 3
(Fig.
Coxal gills on somites 2–7, stalked and subovate, smallest on pereopod 7 (Fig.
Pleonal plates
(Epimera) (Fig.
Male (3.1 mm). Closely resembles female but typically smaller, with fewer setae on appendages, and differing in the following characters: Antenna 1 proportionally longer, up to 46% length of body; primary flagellum with 9 segments. Uropod 2 inner and outer rami subequal in length.
Epithet bakeri honors David Baker, a citizen scientist, conservationist and visionary who has worked for decades to bring together scientists, politicians, funders, regulators and stakeholders from near and far to conserve the watershed of Jacob’s Well. David lived immediately over the underwater cave for some time, working hard to make his own property environmentally friendly and to educate those who visited. He formed the Wimberley Valley Watershed Association, a non-profit with the mission to protect Jacob’s Well and Cypress Creek.
To date, this small species has been collected in 2 karst springs in southwestern Hays and northwestern Comal counties, Texas, a single karst spring 50 km northeast, on the shoreline of the Colorado River (usually emerging beneath a boat dock in Lake Austin) in Austin, Travis County, Texas and 2 karst spring complexes 74 km further northeast in Salado, Bell County, Texas (Fig.
Jacob’s Well (Fig.
John Knox Spring (Fig.
Robertson Springs (Fig.
Groundwater fauna collected at each Stygobromus bakeri sp. nov. site. Stygobionts (S) are hypogean and colonize various groundwater habitats. Crenobionts (C) are epigean and preferentially colonize springs.
Taxon | Stygobiont/c renobiont | John Knox Spring | Jacob‘s Well | Salado Springs | Mormon Spring #3 |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Turbellarians | |||||
Order Tricladida | |||||
Family Kenkiidae | |||||
Sphalloplana mohri Hyman, 1938 | S | X | |||
Annelids | |||||
Order Lumbriculata | |||||
Family Lumbriculidae | |||||
Eremidrilus sp. 1 Fend & Rodriguez, 2003 | S | X | X | ||
Eremidrilus sp. 2 | S | X | |||
Molluscans | |||||
Order Gastropoda | |||||
Family Cochliopidae | |||||
Phreatoceras taylori (Hershler & Longley, 1986) | S | X | |||
Phreatodrobia conica Hershler & Longley, 1986 | S | X | |||
Phreatodrobia micra (Pilsbry & Ferriss, 1906) | S | X | |||
Phreatodrobia nugax (Pilsbry & Ferriss, 1906) | S | X | X | ||
Stygopyrgus bartonensis Hershler & Longley, 1986 | S | X | |||
Family Hydrobiidae | |||||
Marstonia comalensis (Pilsbry & Ferriss, 1906) | C | X | X | X | |
Family Plueroceridae | |||||
Elimia comalensis (Pilsbry, 1890) | C | X | X | ||
Crustaceans | |||||
Order Amphipoda | |||||
Family Parabogidiellidae | |||||
Parabogidiella americana Holsinger, 1980 | S | X | |||
Family Crangonyctidae | |||||
Stygobromus bifurcatus (Holsinger, 1967) | S | X | X | X | |
Stygobromus russelli (Holsinger, 1967) | S | X | X | X | X |
Stygobromus (flagellatus group) sp. nov. Cope, 1872 | S | X | |||
Order Bathynellacea | |||||
Family Parabathynellidae | |||||
Texanobathynella bowmani Delamare Deboutteville, Coineau & Serban, 1975 | S | X | |||
Order Isopoda | |||||
Family Asellidae | |||||
Caecidotea bilineata Lewis & Bowman, 1996 | S | X | |||
Caecidotea reddelli (Steeves, 1968) | S | X | X | ||
Lirceolus bisetus (Steeves, 1968) | X | ||||
Lirceolus hardeni (Lewis & Bowman, 1996) | S | X | X | X | |
Lirceolus pilus (Steeves, 1968) | S | X | X | ||
Order Podocopida | |||||
Family Candonidae | |||||
Comalcandona tressleri Külköylüoğlu & Gibson, 2018 | S | X | |||
Schornikovdona bellensis Külköylüoğlu, Yavuzatmaca, Akdemir, Diaz & Gibson, 2017 | S | X | |||
Pseudocandona albicans (Brady, 1864) | C | X | |||
Pseudocandona cf semicognita (Schäfer, 1934) | C | X | |||
Physocypria cf globula Furtos, 1933 | C | X | |||
Darwinula stevensoni (Brady & Robertson, 1870) | C | X | |||
Cypridopsis sp. (Brady, 1867) | C | X | |||
Physocypria denticulata (Daday, 1905) | C | X | |||
Chlamydotheca texasiensis (Baird, 1862) | C | X | |||
Cypridopsis cf helvetica Kaufmann, 1900 | C | X | |||
Arachnids | |||||
Order Trobidiformes | |||||
Family Arrenuridae | |||||
Arrenurus spp. Dugès, 1834 | S | X | X | ||
Insects | |||||
Order Coleoptera | |||||
Family Dytiscidae | |||||
Sanilippodytes sp. Franciscolo, 1979 | C | X | X | ||
Uvarus texanus (Sharp, 1882) | C | X | |||
Family Elmidae | |||||
Microcyloepus pusillus (LeConte, 1852) | C | X | X | X | |
Salamanders | |||||
Order Urodela | |||||
Family Plethodontidae | |||||
Eurycea chisholmensis Chippindale, Price, Wiens & Hillis, 2000 | C | X | |||
Eurycea pterophila Burger, Smith & Potter, 1950 | C | X | X |
Mormon Spring # 3 (Fig.
Stygobromus bakeri sp. nov. co-occurs with S. russelli (all sites), S. bifurcatus (Jacob’s Well, Salado Springs, and Mormon Springs), and a large undescribed species of Stygobromus in the flagellatus group (Jacob’s Well). The presence of 4 Stygobromus species at Jacob’s Well is notable, and presumably all 4 species occupy different ecological niches. Due to its unusually small size and robust body, S. bakeri sp. nov. is able to inhabit both deep cave and shallow spring habitats. It may also occupy interstitial habitats such as the hyporheic zone of surface streams, although it was not collected in hyporheic samples from Carper’s Creek, near John Knox Spring. The small adult size and general stout teardrop body shape is reminiscent of Seborgia relicta Holsinger, 1980 and S. hershleri Holsinger, 1992 found in groundwater habitats (deep aquifer caves and wells, springs, and hyporheos) throughout the Edwards Plateau and Balcones Escarpment. Seborgia has not been found associated with the Glen Rose formation of the Trinity Aquifer nor with the northernmost section of the Edwards Aquifer extending north of the Colorado River in Austin to Salado where Stygobromus bakeri sp. nov. occurs (Fig.
Species lengths reported from original descriptions for relative comparisons and likely vary.
1a | Gnathopod 2 longer than gnathopod 1 | 2, hubbsi group |
1b | Gnathopod 1 longer or subequal to gnathopod 2 | 3 |
2a | Pereopod 6 and 7 basis broadly expanded posteriorly with dorsoposterior lobe, adults < 6 mm long, central Texas | S. bakeri sp. nov. Gibson & Hutchins |
2b | Pereopod 6 and 7 basis narrow, distoposterior lobe poorly developed, adults ≤ 13 mm long, rare, Culberson County, west Texas | S. limbus Wang & Holsinger, 2001 |
3a | Gnathopod 1 often stouter but subequal in length to gnathopod 2, pereopod 6 and 7 subequal in length | 4 |
3b | Gnathopod 1 stouter and usually longer that gnathopod 2, pereopod 7 longer than pereopod 6 | 8, tenuis group |
4a | Pereopod 4 coxal plate extending distally > ½ length of basis, pereopod 5–7 basis broadly expanded posteriorly, well defined distoposterior lobe, midwest Texas | S. hadenoecus (Holsinger, 1966) |
4b | Pereopod 4 coxal plate extending distally < ½ length of basis, pereopod 5–7 basis posterior margin not entirely expanded, usually narrow or narrows distally with poorly defined distoposterior lobes, central Texas | 5, flagellatus group |
5a | Uropod 3 with ≤ 3 apical setae, gnathopod 1 palmer margin straight or convex, telson with or without lateral setae, medium to large size (11–15 mm long) | 6 |
5b | Uropod 3 typically with ≥ 4 apical setae, gnathopod 1 palmer margin convex, telson without lateral setae, medium size (8–11 mm long) | 7 |
6a | Pereopod 5 basis subtriangular (expanded proximally), gnathopod 1 palmer margin convex with 2 rows each with many (ca. 20) robust bifurcated setae, pereopod 7 dactylus 1/4 length of propodus, telson often with multiple lateral setae (3 pair typical in females), large ≤ 15 mm long | S. flagellatus (Benedict, 1896) |
6b | Pereopod 5 basis narrow (parallel sided), gnathopod 1palmer margin straight, with 2 rows each with fewer (ca. 10) relatively stouter robust bifurcated setae, pereopod 7 dactylus 1/3 length of propodus, telson sometimes with single pair of lateral setae, medium ≤ 11 mm long | S. longipes (Holsinger, 1966) |
7a | Pereopods 5–7 dactylus 1/3 length of propodus; uropod 3 with 3 or 4 apical setae, ≤ 8 mm long, rare, Kendall and northern Bexar counties | S. dejectus (Holsinger, 1967) |
7b | Pereopods 5–7 dactylus 1/4 length of propodus; uropod 3 with 5 apical setae, ≤ 11 mm long, rare, Comal County | S. pecki (Holsinger, 1967) |
8a | Gnathopod palmer margins deeply concave (pronounced in larger specimens) | 9 |
8b | Gnathopod palmer margins straight to convex | 10 |
9a | Lateral sternal gills simple, rare, central Texas, ≤ 16 mm long | S. balconis (Hubricht, 1943) |
9b | Lateral sternal gills bifurcated, widespread in northern Texas, ≤ 10 mm long | S. alabamensis (Stout, 1911) |
10a | Gnathopod 1 palmer margin convex, large (recorded >14 mm long) widespread in central Texas | S. bifurcatus (Holsinger, 1967) |
10b | Gnathopod 1 palmer margin straight, medium to large | 11 |
11a | Pereopod 5–7 slender (pereopod 7 carpus width ca. 15% that of length), pereopod 7 ca. 25% longer than pereopod 5, pereopod 7 basis posterior margin mostly straight (parallel sided), uropod 3 with 3 apical setae, telson with ca. 14 apical setae, large (≤14 mm long) rare, San Saba County | S. reddelli (Holsinger, 1966) |
11b | Pereopod 5–7 less slender (pereopod 7 carpus width ca. 25% that of length), pereopod 7 ≥ 30% longer than pereopod 5, pereopod 5–7 basis posterior margin mostly convex, telson with ca. 11 apical setae, medium sized (≤12 mm long) widespread in central Texas | S. russelli (Holsinger, 1967) |
The description of S. bakeri sp. nov. represents a southeast extension of the known range of the hubbsi group into the eastern Edwards Plateau and Balcones Escarpment of central Texas. Stygobromus putealis, described from eastern Wisconsin is the only other representative of the hubbsi group that occurs east of the western Cordillera of North America (
At all sites where S. bakeri sp. nov. was detected, it occurs in apparently low abundance, particularly compared to co-occurring Stygobromus (e.g. at John Knox Spring, S. bakeri sp. nov. composed 10% of all Stygobromus (27 versus 236 S. russelli) collected from 6 January to 21 May 2010. In comparison, at Robertson Springs, the highest yearly abundance of S. bakeri sp. nov. was 5% of all Stygobromus (26 versus 532 S. russelli and S. bifurcatus combined) collected from 12 April to 7 November 2018. However, it is uncertain whether perceived rarity reflects actual rarity or a lack of effective sampling (
Both Jacob’s Well and John Knox Springs are fed by the Trinity Aquifer, although the recharge area for John Knox Spring has not been delineated. Recharge for Jacob’s Well primarily occurs in an 80 km2 area within the Dry Cypress Creek watershed northwest of the spring (
The listing of several aquifer-obligate species in the adjacent Edwards Aquifer in the 1960s, 1970s, and 1980s spurred formation of the Edwards Aquifer Authority (EAA) in 1993. Charged with protecting minimum spring flows at Comal and San Marcos springs, the EAA implemented programs that helped protect groundwater recharge and reduce groundwater use (including enforcement of pumping limitations). The regulatory actions of the EAA and conservation measures established in the Edwards Aquifer Habitat Conservation Plan (HCP) have been successful in maintaining spring flow despite a rapidly growing population. Indeed, existing models predict that HCP conservation measures are sufficient to maintain springflows during drought-of-record conditions that would otherwise result in spring failure (
Recharge of the northern section of the Edwards Aquifer and groundwater conservation in Salado is not regulated by the EAA. In this section of the aquifer, Clearwater Underground Water Conservation District is responsible for management of groundwater in Bell County. Recharge for the springs where S. bakeri sp. nov. and the federally threatened salamander, Eurycea chisholmensis occur are thought to be in the west and southwest portion of Bell County with flow moving generally southeast (
Mormon Springs is located upstream, but near habitat for the federally endangered Barton Springs and Austin blind salamanders (Eurcyea sosorum Chippindale, Price & Hillis, 1993 and E. waterlooensis Hillis, Chamberlain, Wilcox & Chippindale, 2001), and is in the same aquifer formation as the federally endangered Jollyville Plateau salamander, E. tonkawae Chippindale, Price, Wiens & Hillis, 2000. Little is known about groundwater flow on the northeast side of the Colorado River on the Balcones Escarpment. Mormon Springs is not within a groundwater conservation district, and well pumping, mainly for domestic landscaping use, is unregulated.
The discovery of an undescribed Stygobromus amphipod from the Trinity and Edwards aquifers associated karst springs in Hays, Comal, Travis, and Bell counties in central Texas is unsurprising giving the high species richness and small-range endemism previously reported for the genus and previous documentation of numerous undescribed taxa (
Thanks to the land managers at Jacob’s Well for access to SCUBA and collection in the cave. James Brown and Gregg Tatum are cave divers that helped with cave diving logistics and collection of specimens and assisted author JKK with very technical SCUBA sampling, Krista McDermid helped process specimens. Special thanks to David Baker for logistical support and his decades-long dedication to the conservation of Jacob’s Well. We thank John Knox Ranch for the continual access to their property and their dedication to environmental education and preservation of one of the most pristine streams in the Texas Hill Country, The Robertson family and the Bell County Adaptive Management Coalition for support of conservation research and access to springs, wells, and caves in the area. We greatly appreciate the taxonomic expertise provided by Will Coleman, Steve Fend, Robert Hershler, Okan Külköylüoğlu, Kathryn Perez, and Ian Smith, and specialized knowledge from hydrologist Marcus Gary and field biologists, Andy Gluesenkamp, Jessica Gordon, Chad Norris, James Reddell, Jennifer Bronson Warren, and staff at the San Marcos Aquatic Resources Center.
The views presented herein are those of the authors and do not necessarily represent those of the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service.